The only thing to keep in mind is that silicone lube is unsafe to use with silicone toys because it breaks the toys down and can introduce space for pathogens, like some bacteria, to thrive. She explains that because silicone lubes tend to be more slick and last longer, people experienced in anal play tend to like silicone lube better. Lube is crucial for anal sex because, unlike the vagina, the anus does not lubricate itself. What are some tips for trying anal play for the first time? Both materials are also safe to use with any type of lube, whether water-, oil- or silicone-based. Fleming suggests choosing a small metal or glass butt plug, specifically, because they’re nonporous (so pathogens, like certain bacteria, have a more challenging time settling into the plug) and easy to clean. Eventually, you may want to work up to larger plugs, which can get as big as a fist.ĭr. Small plugs should be roughly the size of a finger or two for easy insertion, so you can gently stretch the tissue around your anus.

The best rule of thumb is that beginners should start with a toy that's smaller in size. There are also heavy, metal butt plugs that provide plenty of pressure. You can find a butt plug that vibrates or one that feels like rimming (mimicking the sensation of someone licking your anus). The best butt plugs come in various sizes, materials, and textures. The good news is that there are lots and lots of safe, fun, and interesting anal sex toys to try out, no matter where you are on your anal-play journey. That’s a good way for a sexy night to go disastrously wrong. “If not, when you orgasm and the muscles contract, it can have a vacuum effect where the toy can slip in and get lost in the rectum,” Megan Fleming PhD, a certified sex therapist and clinical psychologist tells SELF. It’s very important that any sex toy you use for butt play has a flared base. Although you might already have a drawer full of dildos, many dildos aren’t safe for anal penetration. Curious about anal sex? The most important thing to know about this sex toy is that it’s imperative to use the best butt plugs, as you can’t just stick anything up your bum.

Fox tail butt plug in a skirt